Letter from Havana
Surrounded by history but bereft of innovative work from the past four
decades, Cuban architects hope for the future.
By Clifford A. Pearson
March 21, 2014
Making a living as an architect is tough anywhere. But in Cuba it is
essentially impossible. Although Raúl Castro has loosened state control
of the economy a bit, the private sector still barely exists. All
legally-sanctioned construction is done by the government. And everyone
agrees that a government salary doesn’t cover anyone’s monthly expenses.
Cubans, though, are resourceful and somehow find ways to make ends meet.
Over coffee at the Habana Libre Hotel (originally the Havana Hilton), I
kept asking a respected local architect what he was working on and kept
hearing about fascinating research projects, none of which produced any
income. I finally gave up all pretense of politeness and bluntly asked,
“But how do you make money?” He told me on the condition I don’t reveal
his identity: He gives lectures abroad and employs convoluted ways to
bring the funds back home.
Six days in Havana earlier this year introduced me to a place where five
decades of economic stagnation explain only the surface reality: 1958
Chevies still rumbling down the streets, 19th-century villas holding
onto their Neoclassical charms as they fade in the Caribbean sun, and
low-rise streetscapes broken only by church spires or the occasional
Modern tower the same age as those big-bodied cars. Dig a bit deeper,
though, and you find a more complex reality: people like that architect
who somehow push forward despite institutional indifference, opposition,
and a city that is slowly preparing for the future.
A long history of overcoming adversity and a culture rich in
architecture, design, literature, and all kinds of performing arts
provides Havana with a strong foundation on which to build its next
chapter. And as Fidel Castro’s health continues to deteriorate and a
recent survey by the Atlantic Council shows a growing majority of
Americans in favor of more direct engagement with Cuba, progress in
Havana may happen sooner rather than later.
Ironically, the biggest and most obvious changes are happening in the
oldest part of town: La Habana Vieja, where the Office of the City
Historian is busy renovating historic structures and rejuvenating the
trades needed to accomplish this task. Don’t let the quaint, almost
arcane, title deceive you; the City Historian is a powerful agency run
by a dynamic leader, Eusebio Leal Spengler, who reports directly to
President Castro. In the early 1990s, after the Soviet Union collapsed
and its enormous subsidies to Cuba abruptly ended, Leal convinced Fidel
to let him operate his agency on an entrepreneurial basis. The country’s
economy had come to a standstill and desperate times bred unprecedented
experimentation. So the Office of the City Historian was given a small
pot of seed money and granted authority to attract foreign capital for
renovation projects in Old Havana.
Since then, Leal has found foreign (mostly European) banks and companies
to invest in converting decaying buildings into hotels, restaurants, and
commercial spaces, which his agency operates. He takes revenues from
such enterprises and reinvests them in other projects—some that generate
further revenue, but some that provide social services, such as housing,
healthcare, and employment training. Today, the Office of the City
Historian runs hotels, restaurants, a radio station, a publishing house,
a tour company, and an impressive array of cultural facilities. Leal has
his own show broadcast on his agency’s radio station. Everybody in Cuba
Leal has pursued a strategy of self-sustainability for his office as a
whole and applied it to various operations within it too. So he has set
up a series of workshops to train people in trades such as carpentry,
ironwork, and construction, then employs them in the Herculean job of
preserving and renovating the city’s crumbling fabric. The Office of the
City Historian serves as architect for all of its projects, emplying
staff from every design discipline it needs.
The scope of the challenge facing Leal in the early ‘90s was gigantic.
Havana was crumbling, the result of decades of neglect as Castro paid
more attention to the countryside than the capital. Understanding both
the cultural and economic value of the city’s history, Leal focused on
La Habana Vieja. To jump start the process and spread its impact around
the old district, he tackled the city’s five colonial squares (Plaza de
San Francisco, Plaza de Armas, Plaza del Cristo, Plaza Vieja, and Plaza
de La Catedral), restoring the public spaces and many of the buildings
“Time has gone by too fast and we still have so much to do,” says Leal,
sitting in a graciously restored room in the old villa that serves as
offices for him and his staff. Just outside the building, I noticed a
cruise ship docked at the city’s old port. Cruise lines are just
starting to service Havana and Leal admits the city is not prepared to
handle the large numbers of tourists that would descend on it if bigger
ships docked here and the U.S. trade embargo were lifted.
Infrastructure is a huge problem for Havana. The city’s system of street
cars was scrapped well before the Communists took over, so residents
must rely on overcrowded and unreliable buses or 60-year-old American
cars called colectivos that serve as shared taxis. Water, electrical,
and sewage systems are also ancient and failing. Proper highways don’t
exist, so inter-city transport is excruciatingly slow.
Touring Old Havana with Kenia Diaz, the project director in the Office
of the City Historian and Ayleen Robainas, an architect in the same
agency, I couldn’t help but be impressed by their work. Their knowledge
of the city and passion for what they are doing are remarkable. They
understand that restoring a city is about touching the people who live
there, not just retouching the buildings. They showed me the colonial
squares that their agency has used as acupuncture points in healing the
urban body and took me to old palacios converted into hotels or
apartment buildings, a 19th-century pharmacy lovingly restored, and
several of the workshops that produce the crafts and craftsmen needed
for these projects.
They also gave me sneak peeks of two much-anticipated projects: the
renovations of the Teatro Marti and the National Capitol. The theater,
which dates from the late 19th century and had been closed since the
1980s, reopened in February, just a couple of weeks after my visit.
Although I wasn’t crazy about the new glass-and-metal canopy that covers
the walkway to the main entrance, I was wowed by the lovingly restored
interior with its curving iron balconies and rococo proscenium stage.
Hidden from sight are new mechanical, electrical, and fire-safety
systems, and a new backstage that make the theater work for live theater
and musical performances.
Just a block away, El Capitolio is getting a multi-year overhaul that
will allow it to serve as the home of the nation’s parliament for the
first time since 1959. Modeled after the U.S. Capitol, but injected with
architectural steroids, the enormous Neoclassical building most recently
served as home base for the Ministry of Science, Technology and
Environment. Decades of deferred maintenance, though, took a big toll on
the building’s mighty dome and acres of marble.
Now closed and under scaffolding, the Capitol is getting repaired, first
from the top (its dome and upper floors of offices) and then the bottom
(its grand lobby, hallways, and two assembly halls). Diaz, from the City
Historian’s Office, says her agency hopes to open the office floors in a
year and a half and compete the entire project in about seven years.
Everyone I spoke with agreed that the work being done in Old Havana has
made a significant improvement, even if the buildings in need of repair
still greatly outnumber those that have received help. Some important
architects, though, bemoan the fact that almost nothing has been done
outside the city’s colonial core. Eduardo Luis Rodríguez, who has
written books on modern Havana and is serving as an advisor to the
Museum of Modern Art on an upcoming exhibition on Latin American Modern
architecture, wishes that the same attention being given to La Habana
Vieja would be applied to areas such as El Vedado and Miramar, where
much of the city’s 20th-century architecture resides. In these newer
districts you’ll find wonderful examples of tropical Modernism, such as
the Habana Libre (designed by Welton Beckett & Associates in the late
1950s along with the Cuban firm Arroyo y Menendez), the Riviera Hotel
(designed by Polevitzky, Johnson and Associates for the gangster Meyer
Lansky in 1957), and buildings by talented Cuban architects such as
Frank Martinez, Mario Romañach, Max Borges Recio, and Rafael de Cárdenas.
Mario Coyula, a much respected architect, planner, and writer, also
sounds the alarm on Havana’s endangered Modern heritage. “Time is
critical,” he told me over coffee at his apartment in El Vedado. “Many
buildings are near collapse and need to be stabilized.” Part of the
problem is that while most Havana residents own their apartments, no one
owns—or takes care of—the buildings containing them. He also worries
about the soul of Havana. “Back in the 1950s, Miami was a sleepy city,
while Havana was a vibrant place.” Though he is concerned that Havana is
not prepared for a rapid influx of investment, should the embargo be
lifted, he said, “The future of Havana is linked to Miami.”
Coyula notes that Modern architecture in Cuba didn’t end with the fall
of the Batista regime. For the first six or seven years of Castro’s
rule, the government commissioned progressive architects to design
housing, sports venues, and schools, and let them pursue innovative
strategies. The most prominent of these projects was the set of five
national schools of art that were the focus of John Loomis’ 1999 book
Revolution of Forms. Orchestrated by Ricardo Porro in 1961 and designed
by him, Vittorio Garatti, and Roberto Gottardi, the schools of plastic
arts, modern dance, dramatic arts, music, and ballet leaped off the
ground with thin-shelled domes, concrete arches, and undulating Catalan
vaults. But as the project moved forward, political backing for it
waned. When construction stopped in 1965 only three of the schools were
completed, while the other two were just partially built.
In 2012 Cuban dancer Carlos Acosta, who had studied in his homeland and
then became a star at the Royal Ballet in London, announced that Norman
Foster had agreed to renovate and complete Garatti’s National School of
Ballet. The least finished of the five schools, the ballet building had
never been used and was abandoned except for the occasional student who
wandered over in search of a quiet place to practice his violin or draw.
But Garatti is still very much alive and was taken aback that he wasn’t
consulted or involved in the project. Most of the Cuban architects I
spoke with said Garatti should be the one to renovate his building and
that all the outside players in the Foster proposal made it a nonstarter
with the Cuban government anyway.
Frustration seems to be a way of life in Cuba. From the lack of
political expression to the daily effects of the U.S. trade embargo,
Cubans navigate an economic and emotional terrain that presents
obstacles at every turn. Talking with architects in Havana, I was
charmed by their warmth, intellect, and graciousness. But there was a
sadness too, a recognition that despite all the talent on this island,
they could point to very little new or daring that had been built in the
last four decades.
Source: Letter from Havana – News – Architectural Record –