Posted on Saturday, 03.08.14
Mexico’s new friend: Castro’s Cuba
BY ANDRES OPPENHEIMER
MEXICO CITY — There are many theories about why Mexico is cozying up to
Cuba’s dictatorship and looking the other way as Venezuelan President
Nicolás Maduro brutally represses street demonstrations, but I think the
most credible one can be summed up in one word — fear.
Well-placed foreign policy analysts tell me that Mexican President
Enrique Peña Nieto’s disregard for the defense of universal rights and
basic freedoms in Cuba and Venezuela is partly due to fear that these
two countries could use their clout with Mexico’s leftist movements to
stir up trouble at home.
Peña Nieto has recently passed ambitious energy, education, and
telecommunications reforms that have gained enthusiastic applause from
Wall Street, but that most of Mexico’s left opposes. The last thing Peña
Nieto wants is for Cuba and Venezuela to encourage these leftist groups
to derail the reforms in Congress, or through protests on the streets.
“Cuba and Venezuela are domestic policy issues in Mexico,” says Miguel
Hakim, a former Mexican undersecretary of foreign affairs in charge of
Latin American affairs. “The Peña Nieto government does not want them to
stir up the pot at home while he is trying to implement his energy and
Late last year, Peña Nieto forgave 70 percent of Cuba’s nearly $500
million foreign debt to his country. During an official visit to the
island in January, he met with semi-retired Cuban dictator Fidel Castro
and praised him as “Cuba’s political and moral leader.” The Peña Nieto
government has also remained largely silent on Maduro repression of
street protests that have already left 20 dead.
Close aides to Peña Nieto told me that Mexico’s foreign policy is guided
by pragmatism, and by a desire to be a major player in Latin America’s
diplomatic community. During the recent governments of Vicente Fox
(2000-2006) and Felipe Calderón (2006-2012), of the opposition National
Action Party, Mexico had adopted a more pro-human rights, pro-democracy
stand regarding Cuba and Venezuela, which had infuriated those
“We have a very pragmatic view of how we should conduct our foreign
policy,” Peña Nieto’s chief of staff Aurelio Nuño told me in an
interview last week. “In the case of Venezuela, we prefer to be prudent.
We do not believe that strident positions will be very useful.”
Most South American countries, led by Brazil, are openly backing the
Maduro government in Venezuela. But Brazil’s support for Cuba and
Venezuela — which is much more explicit than Mexico’s — comes as less of
a surprise, because it is consistent with Brazil’s shameless foreign
policy regarding democracy and human rights issues in recent years.
In its quest to become a Third World power, Brazil has befriended some
of the bloodiest dictators in the Americas, Africa and Asia. Also,
Brazil’s leftist government has been pursuing free market economic
policies, while keeping its leftwing base happy with a pro-Cuba,
pro-Venezuela foreign policy. Brazil has also invested heavily in Cuba
and Venezuela’s oil and infrastructure projects over the past 10 years.
Among the few Latin American governments that have expressed concern
about the bloodshed in Venezuela are Chile, Peru, Colombia and Panama.
Outgoing Chilean president Sebastian Piñera told me in an interview last
month that Latin American countries “share a commitment to defend
freedom, democracy and human rights not only within our borders, but
also outside them.”
My opinion: Peña Nieto’s policy toward Cuba and Venezuela is not
“pragmatism,” but — in addition to a shameful disregard for Latin
American treaties committing countries to defend universal rights — is a
textbook case of diplomatic over-reaction.
If Peña Nieto wanted to keep Cuba and Venezuela from firing up Mexico’s
left, he could have done the same with polite diplomacy, without the
need to praise as a “moral leader” a dictator who is responsible for
thousands of deaths and has not allowed a free election in five decades.
In an effort to distance himself from his predecessors, Peña Nieto has
In addition, Peña Nieto’s new friendship with Cuba will hurt Mexico’s
image. Mexico’s recent passage of long-delayed economic reforms has
turned this country once again into a darling of the international
financial community, but if Mexico tries to sell itself to the world as
a modern democracy, it will not help itself by teaming up with Cuba and
Mexico will have a harder time joining the First World if it embraces
some of the most retrograde regimes of the Third World.
Source: MEXICO CITY: Andres Oppenheimer: Mexico’s new friend: Castro’s
Cuba – Andres Oppenheimer – MiamiHerald.com –